Post a Comment
Share with a friend

November 12, 2009

Baby Einstein Refunds


Whenever I think I'm doing a decent job of raising my kids, something happens to convince me that I am, in fact, profoundly inept at the job.

Most recently it was the news that the Baby Einstein company is offering refunds to anyone who bought its DVDs in the last five years. Here's why: Turns out the show doesn't actually make kids any smarter.

I know. It's shocking. Next they'll tell us that Froot Loops are NOT actually part of a nutritious breakfast, and that sparing the rod does NOT in fact spoil the child. Where will the madness end?

The Einstein videos — and the Baby Beethovens, da Vincis, and Wordsworths that make up the whole lofty-tot series — have long been promoted as educational, said to stimulate babies' brains. But a child advocacy group called the claims untrue and threatened Disney with a class-action lawsuit, citing studies that prove such shows actually delay language development.

In other words, the more they see, the less they know. Which is sort of how I feel about my parenting skills.

Confession: I'm one of the lousy moms who strapped her infants into their no-escape high-chairs, pushed them in front of the television and popped in a Baby Mozart video. I did it with frequency and I did it with confidence, believing for no good reason that the images of low-budget puppets nodding to sonatas would spark synapses in my boys' burgeoning, Harvard-bound brains.

Because it was either that or my well-worn copy of The Rocky Horror Picture Show.


123 Next >>

Comments


Eleven or twelve years ago my boss, since his girls had gotten older, gave me his VHS tape of a show like this called "So Smart." It was classical music to the scenes of computer-generated shapes growing and changing, and yes, the occasional puppet. Very pretty music and absolutely absorbing for an infant. What is funny is, at one point there was a puppet dragon who opened his mouth and his tongue unfurled like a little red carpet and he went "Blah!" This is the only image from the tape which my kids remember, because it terrified them. It haunts their dreams still. They are 12 and 8, and they still literally shudder about it, which makes me laugh, because I am a lousy and insensitive parent.

George

Thu Nov 12, 2009


When our son was a baby we gave him to Gypsies until he learned how to pickpocket a fob watch in a nudist colony... Our foresight paid off when the economy tanked and he is now not only paying his tuition, but a significant portion of the bills. And who could have foreseen that the philosophy he learned from stealing would pay off so well in the business world of today? Oh, and he listened to Queen and Black Sabbath as a baby.

Lee Jenkinson

Sat Nov 14, 2009


Post a Comment:

Name:
E-mail (will not be displayed):
Comment:
To help prevent spam, please re-enter the word that appears in pink below:

We reserve the right to edit or remove comments at our discretion.


<< Previous column View more Parenting columns Next column >>

Share this column with a friend

readers respond:

"The perfect amount of sass, humor, and contemplative sensitivity."


*

Search:


*

Recent columns:

July 15, 2010
Mini-Cakes

July 8, 2010
Why Have Kids? No, Really.

July 1, 2010
Take This Ring and ...

June 24, 2010
I Ain't No Supermodel

June 17, 2010
Relationship Dissection

More >>


*

Most
E-mailed:

Home School

Breast Milk Canapé

Enough for Two

Book Club's Dramatic Chapter

Fall From Cool

More >>



The contents of this site are © Starshine Roshell.
All rights reserved. Site by Comicraft.